New universe Logo and home pageClick for full information.
Back BarExplanation bar
New Universe: Archives Important Information: Status Report  To Advertise Here: Information Universe Related

Final Anthropic Principle is the existence of intelligence in the Universe


Critics of the Final Anthropic Principle claim that its arguments violate the Copernican principle
Critics of the Final Anthropic Principle claim that its arguments violate the Copernican principle

The final anthropic principle (FAP) is defined by physicists John D. Barrow and Frank J. Tipler's 1986 book "The Anthropic Cosmological Principle" as a generalization of the anthropic principle as follows:

  • Final anthropic principle (FAP): "Intelligent information-processing must come into existence in the Universe, and, once it comes into existence, it will never die out."

Barrow and Tipler state that, although the FAP is a purely physical statement, the "validity of the FAP is the physical precondition for moral values to arise and so to continue to exist in the universe: no moral values of any sort can exist in a lifeless cosmology." Furthermore, the FAP seems to imply a melioristic cosmos (a tendency throughout nature toward improvement).

The FAP does not imply stability of the Proton: it is possible to process information using the Quantum number and spin state of positronium atoms (although the positronium Half-Life of 100 nanoseconds would require other, more stable, particles to also exist).

Barrow and Tipler make a "very tentative prediction" that the FAP appears to imply that the Universe is either flat or closed (and not open; see topology of the universe).

Critics of the Final Anthropic Principle claim that its arguments violate the Copernican principle, that it incorrectly applies the laws of probability, and that it is really a theology or metaphysics principle made to sound plausible to laypeople by using the esoteric language of physics.

Arguments to justify the eventual extinction of life

Many scientists have used the Second Law of Thermodynamics to argue that "life" (defined by Barrow and Tipler to be information processing capability) must eventually die out. Occasionally, such proofs are based on the improbable assumption that the universe remains at a constant temperature; despite evidence that the Universe is cooling (and thus heat engines operate with increasing efficiency).

Barrow and Tipler consider such arguments and quote Pierre Duhem, who wrote in 1914:

"The deduction [of the Heat Death from the Second Law of thermodynamics] is marred in more than one place by fallacies. First of all, it implicitly assumes the assimilation of the universe to a finite collection of bodies isolated in a space absolutely devoid of matter; and this assimilation exposes one to many doubts. Once this assimilation is admitted, it is true that the Entropy of the universe has to increase endlessly, but it does not impose any lower or upper limit on this entropy; nothing then would stop this magnitude varying from -\infty to +\infty as time itself varied from -\infty to +\infty; then the allegedly demonstrated impossibilities regarding an eternal life for the universe would vanish"

Selected quotes which assume FAP

  • "Were one to adopt a teleological view of Nature, one could go so far as to assert that matter has many of its properties today not because these properties are necessary for life today, but because these properties will be essential for the existence of life in the distant future", Barrow and Tipler, "The Anthropic Cosmological Principle", p674.
  • "We see that if life evolves in all of the many universes in a quantum cosmology, and if life continues to exist in all of these universes, then all of these universes, which include all possible histories among them, will approach the Omega point. At the instant the Omega Point is reached, life will have gained control of all matter and forces not only in a single universe, but in all universes whose existence is logically possible; life will have spread into all spatial regions in all universes which could logically exist, and will have stored an infinite amount of information, including all bits of knowledge which it is logically possible to know. And this is the end". Ibid, p676

References

  • John D. Barrow, Frank J. Tipler, The Anthropic Cosmological Principle (1988 edition) Oxford University Press, ISBN 0-19-282147-4



  Print Version    Print This Article  


the web this site
 | Additional Information: WorldWideWeb | Privacy | Sale of Goods | Webmaster | Contact Info | Links
 All Rights Reserved. Copyright Statement.  Top of Page  hit counter